At the end of December 2025, Nassau County had 1,680 single-family homes for sale. That was about 100 fewer than at the end of 2024, when there were 1,782. Six months later, at the end of June 2026, there were 2,509. If you're comparing Nassau towns and wondering whether to keep looking through the holidays or wait for spring, that gap looks like reason enough to wait.
The same OneKey MLS records point the other way on price. In the two winters they cover, the homes that sold in Nassau went for less of their original asking price than in any other season. Supply is thin in winter, and so is the price premium, and the time each home spends on the market helps a buyer tell the listings apart.
The shelf is thinnest from October through December
Months of supply is the number of homes for sale divided by the average monthly pace of signed contracts over the prior year. In Nassau it falls to its lowest level each fourth quarter. It was 2.4 months at the end of Q4 2025 and 2.6 months at the end of Q4 2024. By comparison, it was 3.6 months at the end of Q2 2026 and 3.3 months at the end of Q3 2026.
New listings drive most of that drop. Sellers listed 2,014 single-family homes in Q4 2025, compared with 3,922 in Q2 2026, close to half as many. This fall is already heading the same way. Nassau had 929 new single-family listings in September 2026, 10.4% fewer than in September 2025.
Buyers keep signing after sellers stop listing
Signed contracts fall in winter too, but by much less than listings. In Q4 2025, buyers went into contract on 1,923 single-family homes while sellers brought 2,014 new ones to market, about 95 contracts for every 100 new listings. In Q2 2026, the peak of spring, there were 2,609 contracts against 3,922 new listings, about 67 for every 100. The previous winter followed the same pattern, with 1,895 contracts against 2,006 new listings in Q4 2024.
When contracts come close to matching new listings, some of the homes going under contract must have been listed in an earlier quarter. Winter buyers are choosing among homes carried over from the fall as well as the few new listings.
Winter sales close further below asking
OneKey tracks how much of the original list price a home sells for, averaged across every home that closed in the period. In Nassau that figure follows the calendar. Single-family homes sold for 100.4% of original list price in Q2 2026 and 100.5% in Q3 2026. They sold for 98.6% in Q4 2025 and 98.1% in Q1 2026. The year before looks the same, with 100.6% in Q3 2024, 99.2% in Q4 2024 and 98.4% in Q1 2025.
Time on market moves the other way. In OneKey's figures, days on market is the average time from listing to accepted offer. For Nassau single-family homes it was 39 days in Q3 2026, 46 in Q4 2025 and 57 in Q1 2026. In Q1 2025 it reached 65.
So in the quarters with the fewest homes for sale, sales take longer and close further below the original asking price. One reasonable explanation is that winter sales include more homes that went unsold through the fall, although the county totals do not show when each home was first listed. A well-priced house that comes on the market in December still faces very few competing new listings.
The median sale price drops in winter for a related reason. Nassau's single-family median was $880,000 in Q3 2026, compared with $832,000 in Q4 2025 and $840,000 in Q1 2026. Part of that dip reflects which homes sell in winter, not only what the same house would bring. Year over year, values are still rising. The Q3 2026 median was 2.9% above Q3 2025, and sellers received 100.5% of original list price, up from 99.9% a year earlier.
This fall adds higher mortgage rates
Higher borrowing costs arrived alongside this year's seasonal slowdown. Freddie Mac's average 30-year fixed rate was 7.18% for the week ending November 5, 2026, and 7.11% for the week ending November 12. Newsday reported on November 12 that the seasonal dip in Long Island sales had coincided with a jump in mortgage rates, and that the 7.18% average was nearly a full percentage point above the rate a year earlier.
Higher rates usually push down the price buyers can afford. On Long Island they also discourage owners from selling. In the same Newsday article, real estate analyst and appraiser Jonathan Miller said, "the higher the rates go, the stronger the reason for a homeowner to stay out of the market." Newsday added that, according to the Federal Housing Finance Agency, about 49% of outstanding U.S. residential mortgages carried a rate of 4% or less as of the second quarter of 2026. So the winter shortage of new listings may be deeper than usual this year.
Strong listings are still drawing competition. In that Newsday report, a Manhasset associate broker said attractive houses "are still achieving multiple offers in the first week or two on the market, but each house is getting fewer offers," and described a listing priced just under $2.2 million that received six offers. Long Island Business News reported on October 16 that Contour Mortgage's Huntington branch manager, Jesse Sasso, said "significant price reductions won't happen until inventory increases." Both comments fit the OneKey figures, where winter sales close a point or two below original asking price but stay close to it.
The monthly figures show the turn already under way. Nassau's single-family median sale price was $860,000 in September 2026, below August's $911,000 but 2.1% higher than September 2025, according to Long Island Business News. September's homes averaged 40 days on market, and sellers received 99.8% of original list price. Both figures sit between summer's numbers and last winter's.
Sorting listings by age
For a buyer comparing Nassau towns this winter, these figures suggest dividing the search into two groups that call for different approaches.
The first group is homes that came on the market after Labor Day and are still for sale in December or January. With county averages of 46 days on market in Q4 2025 and 57 in Q1 2026, a home that has been listed well beyond that range stands out. Its price history and days on market are the starting point for any offer, since its seller has already had a full fall season of showings.
The second group is homes listed in December or later that are priced in line with recent sales. These are the homes the Manhasset broker described. When contracts in Q4 2025 nearly matched new listings, a new listing priced right was competing against very few alternatives. An offer on one of these homes usually has to be ready to go in the first week or two, with financing lined up at today's rates and not at last year's.
How much each group matters depends on the town. Nassau's county-wide figures mix very different markets, and we've written before about how much a single median can hide, in our look at Syosset, Jericho and Woodbury and at the two markets within Plainview's ZIP code. In both, the seasonal pattern holds while the price levels differ. If you're coming from an apartment in Queens, our Queens-to-Nassau overview covers the basics that come before timing.
Waiting for spring brings more choice. In Q2 2026, sellers brought nearly twice as many new homes to market as in Q4 2025. Spring buyers also paid more than asking on average, at 100.4% of original list price that quarter, compared with 98.1% in the winter quarter before it. Some buyers will happily pay that for a wider choice of homes. For others, the right house may already be on the market, and the winter figures show buyers paying less of the asking price than they do in spring.
Rates and costs in this post are general information as of their stated dates, not financial or legal advice. Confirm your own numbers with your lender and the appropriate professionals.
If you're weighing a winter offer in Nassau, the agents at Skyline Residential & Commercial Inc. can pull the full price and listing history for any home on your list, so you'll know whether it has been for sale since summer or came on last week. If you own a home and want to see how it would compare with the listings buyers are seeing this winter, start with a home valuation or contact us.